This week the Sydney Swans player Isaac Heeney and his partner were followed and filmed arguing in a local park in the wake of investigations into an incident at a Melbourne hotel in August that led to his suspension. Last week it was the Australian cricket captain Pat Cummins and wife Becky who were filmed in a heated discussion outside their Sydney home after Usman Khawaja made new claims about the infamous “sandpapergate” incident.
While both men have had questions swirling around them that have thrust them squarely into public discussion, this ogling of their personal lives during harrowing moments has raised questions. Most notably about who deserves privacy in a time when the public has become so accustomed to the sharing of private information that they feel entitled to know the details of the personal lives of every public figure.
In Heeney’s case it is perhaps reasonable to question whether he has earned the right to privacy. While he has denied any criminal wrongdoing and Victoria police have confirmed no charges will be laid against him or any of the other Swans players, it is understandable that the actions of professional athletes are heavily scrutinised – particularly for serious allegations such as sexual assault. Heeney was rightly the subject of discussions about whether it was appropriate for him to receive Sydney’s 2026 best and fairest award while investigations into the incident at the Pullman Hotel were still ongoing.
However, where do we draw the line? There is a difference between scrutinising allegations that have the potential to bring the club and the sport into disrepute, and the strange voyeurism of watching two people try to salvage a deeply personal relationship. Whatever we may think of Heeney and how he has handled this incident, there is no public interest in watching him argue with his partner or speculating on whether their relationship will survive.
For even if you argue that Heeney has forfeited his right to privacy through his actions, his partner has no wrongdoing (alleged or otherwise) to answer for – she was not involved in the incident and is not a representative of the Swans. Neither was Becky Cummins in the change rooms in South Africa when the players were or were not aware of sandpaper being brought in to tamper with the ball.
Even if we believe that athletes accused of misconduct are fair game for public speculation at all times, it is hard to make an argument in favour of their partners being thrown to the wolves for clicks.
While some may argue that both of these private discussions happened in public places and are therefore open to public scrutiny, there is simply no reason we need to know about either of them. Although it is easy to film people without their consent thanks to smartphones and the rise of smartglasses, it is even easier to turn away and let people have a difficult moment in private. Not every aspect of the human experience needs to be recorded, distributed and discussed – even if the people in question are public figures.







