‘Time for a circuit breaker’: Cricket Australia creates forum for players to air views on sandpapergate

‘Time for a circuit breaker’: Cricket Australia creates forum for players to air views on sandpapergate

Cricket Australia has announced the creation of an independent “forum” for players and staff to share their accounts of the infamous South Africa tour of 2018 in the hope it provides a “circuit breaker” to the ongoing sandpaper saga.

Speaking next to a children’s playground outside Bellerive Oval in Hobart before the third one-day international between Australia and England, David Boon, the interim CA chair, and chief executive Todd Greenberg insisted the intention is not to “re-litigate” events eight years ago and it will not lead to further sanctions.

Instead, Boon said, this process is about “creating an opportunity for those who wish to be heard to tell their stories in a respectful, safe environment – and for our sport to listen”.

Boon added: “It’s been a difficult chapter for many people, and increasingly, the ongoing debate has become a distraction for our game. We believe it is time for a circuit breaker.”

The creation of this forum – one that is set to be independently chaired by a senior legal figure and is hoped to be completed inside the next month – follows a fortnight of acrimony in Australian cricket that was triggered by the publication of Usman Khawaja’s autobiography, Sabr, and some of the claims within.

Khawaja wrote that ball-tampering with sandpaper occurred earlier on that doomed South Africa tour and knowledge of its use went beyond the three players – Steve Smith, David Warner and Cameron Bancroft – who were hit with significant bans.

Both Warner and reserve bowler Chadd Sayers have publicly supported Khawaja’s version of events since, either side of the current Test captain, Pat Cummins, refuting them in a marathon press conference in Sydney last week.

Amid reports that Bancroft is now ready to go public with his recollections – a potentially explosive account that could in theory make Cummins vulnerable if he is shown to have misled the public – CA have provided an alternative avenue.

“Cameron is entitled, just like every other player, to share his views,” Greenberg said. “He can use this mechanism to share his views, he can share them publicly. No one is compelled to participate. It is entirely up to each individual.”

Greenberg, head of the players’ union back in 2018, has stressed the investigation into events was concluded at the time and that individuals will be free to speak now without fear of recrimination. The process is to be confidential, albeit the CA board will review the material and make a decision whether to issue public conclusions.

Speaking on Fox Cricket after the announcement, Khawaja took issue with that last point. In essence, the former opener believes that evidence being filtered through the governing body’s lens at the end means the process is inherently flawed.

“The biggest question I have … is the board makes the decisions on what [is made public] at the end,” Khawaja said. “How is that an actual way of trying to present what people have said?

“I respect what he [Greenberg] is trying to do there. But at the end of the day, if you’re going to cherry-pick what is said in this report, the board can choose whatever they want to come in or come out. Are we just going in a circle here?”

Warner added: “Where do we actually end here? Because it is on the board to review what they want to be published. OK, yes, that’s a safe space, but is everyone going to be able to talk?. It’s not about penalties. It’s just about coming up with transparency and accountability.”

skip past newsletter promotion


Usman Khawaja and David Warner on commentary duty for Kayo Sports. Photograph: James Ross/AAP/AP

Greenberg had earlier praised Cummins and head coach Andrew McDonald for continuing the cultural reset of the Australian men’s team that occurred in the wake of the scandal. Warner, who has felt a deep sense of injustice, was called a “special human” for the way he returned to cricket after his 12-month ban.

Asked if he was uncomfortable with the fact that the recollections of Khawaja and Cummins are so wildly contrasting that one is not telling the truth, Greenberg replied: “I think they can both be true because it’s their version of events.

“Their version of events is their truth. I’m not here to tell someone what they should believe. Nor should they tell me what I should believe. My version of events might be different to yours. They can be true to you and to me. That’s the difficulty.”

Darren Lehmann, who stood down as Australia men’s head coach in the aftermath of the scandal and has since shied away from publicly discussing the events in any great detail, told ABC Radio that he likes the idea behind this forum.

Lehmann said: “I think it gives players and staff and everyone involved in a very sad time in Australian cricket – and obviously, I was there – a chance to speak. For me, it’s the light at the end of the tunnel.”

Earlier on Wednesday, Test great Ian Healy said Australian cricketers on the sandpaper tour will be remembered as “liars forever” while questioning why Khawaja reignited the debate with the release of his book eight years after the fact.

“Hopefully we got close to the truth in the investigation; those who didn’t get an interview and didn’t go forward, they’re guilty whistleblowers now,” Healy said on SEN radio. “They didn’t come forward when it was saveable, now there’s a massive stain on cricket and they’ll be known as liars forever.

“There is no reason this should have been rehashed. This was not Uzzy’s story to tell, he wasn’t involved and didn’t do anything. Why write about that? He should have done it the day after the occurrence. It’s Davey’s book to write.”

OR

Scroll to Top